Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

Press Sample

Hi all! Now I haven't done a comparison post in a long time! Mostly because they can be a lot of work and not always a reward. Well because after swatching the Indie Fest collection, I was genuinely curious about dupes, I decided it was time for a comparison post! Sometimes, I like to do this because (well before the quarantine), I do have friends that I donate polish to! Some use it for themselves (especially since not everyone can afford nail polish) and some help me to donate to organizations. So I do like to go through my polishes so I can gift the love of polish to others. Well, no dupes here, so I'd like to share my super deep investigation of this nail polish! LOL.

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

Index: Jessica Cosmetics Peony: 3 coats plus top coat.
Middle: Jessica Cosmetics Center Stage: 3 coats plus top coat.
Ring: Jessica Phenom U Had Me at Hello: 3 coats plus top coat.
Pinky: Jessica Phenom Laffy Taffy: 3 coats plus top coat.

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

These really are slightly different colors. The closest would be Peony and Center Stage, but Peony is definitely brighter than Center Stage. U Had Me at Hello has more orange than the other colors and Laffy Taffy is a much lighter pink. No dupes!

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

Index: Jessica Cosmetics Cool in the Pool: 3 coats plus top coat.
Middle: Jessica Cosmetics Headliner: 3 coats plus top coat.
Ring:Jessica Cosmetics Headliner: 3 coats plus top coat.
Pinky: Jessica Phenom Smooth Talker: 3 coats plus top coat.

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

Cool in the Pool definitely has more blue in it than the other two colors. I knew that I had to compare Headliner and Smooth Talker, both from Spring 2020. The difference is minimal and definitely more obvious in person. Smooth Talker has the slightest bit more white in it. I know it is subtle, but they are not the same. I love blues like this so I am keeping them all!

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

Index: Jessica Cosmetics Dream Catcher: 2 coats.
Middle: Jessica Cosmetics Haute Hippie: 2 coats.
Ring: Jessica Cosmetics Dream Catcher: 2 coats.
Pinky: Jessica Cosmetics Haute Hippie: 2 coats.

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

These looked closer in the bottles, but as you can see, these are not similar by any means! But when I applied Dream Catcher, I totally thought of Haute Hippie. Haute Hippie is much darker and makes sense, since it was a fall collection color. Both are almost one coaters! Love them!

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

Index: Jessica Cosmetics Posh: 3 coats.
Middle: Jessica Cosmetics Petal Power: 3 coats.
Ring: Jessica Cosmetics Pumpkin Spice: 3 coats.
Pinky: Jessica Phenom Chocolate Bronze: 3 coats.

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

Again, no dupes here, but Posh and Petal Power are close. Posh is brighter and more coral. Petal Power has a dusty undertone. I thought Pumpkin Spice would be close to Petal Power, but I was so wrong! Pumpkin Spice is much more orange and bright. Chocolate Bronze looked close to Power Petal in the bottle, but on the nail, not at all. It's much more milk chocolate. Keeping them all.

Jessica Cosmetics Indie Fest Spring 2020 Comparisons

So as you can see, no exact dupes here. There were some close ones, most Headliner vs Smooth Talker, but they are all excellent cremes. The Indie Fest collection is available now! Some of the colors are from older collections (like 2014!) so they may not be available. Each of these colors retail for $9 but they have been having lots of awesome sales!

Jessica Cosmetics: SHOP, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest. 

Products in the post were provided for honest review.

Ehmkay Nails on Facebook.
Ehmkay Nails on Instagram.
Ehmkay Nails on Pinterest.
Follow Ehmkay Nails with Bloglovin.